Who would be the top 3 greatest pornstar return of all time?

[paulyshoresituation]

Which retired ex pornstar would you want to make a comeback or come back and even do just one porn scene where you say would probably be the biggest return of all time?


Let's make it a top 3. Now the girl could have done porn for a short time or it could be someone who done porn for several years. Think several years is the sweet spot. Or it could be someone that did porn for a long time but if that is the case, most likely it wouldn't be that amazing since they would be way overexposed.


To me, they would be


Suzie Diamond

Anna Lacey (Priscilla)

Lucy Lee



Of course, these women to me are the best three looking pornstars of all time. Recall claudia rossi mentioned few years ago about a comeback but she didn't do it, think she made only few solo videos. She is one of the private girls from that era though i don't find her anywhere as hot as suzie or lucy.



Now all of them are in their late thirties. Think the cutoff current age for a returning ex pornstar return that would still excite me is someone in their early 40s at the most, like angel dark etc. But someone like julia taylor who is mid 40s would be a bit too old for my liking. Assuming they still look good, that to me would be better than any porn scene from any of the current pornstars nowadays or in the last decade. Personally the two best looking current pornstars to me in the last decade are vinna reed and freya dee. But they don't come close to the other girls from back then.



Also as of now, which pornstar return that has happened would you say is the greatest return of all time? Heard most returns are disappointing right?



Now if a porn site offered suzie, priscilla or lucy a crazy amount of money for a porn scene... of course this would be available on a major online porn site so it would be public, do you think any of them would do it? Let say it was something ridiculous like 500k. Would any of them object? Or that isn't enough for privacy since most don't want that chapter in their life opened again? Would the number being much lower be enough assuming they aren't rich or well off? For example heard years ago jane darling no longer wanted any contact with her old fellow pornstars and she was with a rich old guy etc. So obviously she would never need to do it.



Feel like tons of fans of suzie or priscilla or lucy would go crazy if they were to make a comeback.

[misangrenegra2]

Based on their popularity i would say these 3:

- Jenna Jameson
- Silvia Saint
- Sasha Grey

[ExtremePornFan]

Arwen Gold



Nikita Bellucci



Belle Claire

[asaleh001806]

Arwen Gold



Nikita Bellucci



Belle Claire

Agree, 3 of the best pornstars out there.

[netzerkaiser]

Its a great question.

I need time for this.

So you're prepared to see them 10 years older, much heavier, right?

Its a great question.

[ToryLaneRulez]

Tory Lane

Angel Long


Audrey Hollander

Kelly Wells

any of those in their hetfay workinh for LP

damm that would have been hardvore!!!!!!!

[ExtremePornFan]

Tory Lane

Angel Long


Audrey Hollander

Kelly Wells

any of those in their hetfay workinh for LP

damm that would have been hardvore!!!!!!!

I would love to see trash talking Kelly Wells drinking piss and taking DAP gang-bangs. She would would be a great Legal Porno girl.

[netzerkaiser]

Tory Lane

Angel Long


Audrey Hollander

Kelly Wells

any of those in their hetfay workinh for LP

damm that would have been hardvore!!!!!!!

I think you're onto something!

[ExtremePornFan]

Arwen Gold

Nikita Bellucci

Belle Claire

Agree, 3 of the best pornstars out there.

I bet they would be top 10 for most die hard Legal Porno Fans. I am really interested to see what people come up with. There have been so many porn starts that have come and gone. 100's of girls that only done a few scenes. Great Post paulyshoresituation it has legs.

[dap-addict]

I am really interested to see what people come up with.

Me, too!
OP was clear for 2 girls, 1 I was a bit surprised.
As netzer I need more time for that.

But generally neither Belle Claire nor Arwen Gold I would completely exclude possibility, now that we had Angie Moon, Ria Sunn and most recently July Sun back.

[avanfurwet]

Cherry Jul.

[pjfry75]

Hard one but recently:

[zeusanalfreak299]

I based my choice on the assumption that they would return with the same body they had when they retired. For big cock gangbangs (including interracial ala Waka Waka).

Just a little older and more mature in terms of skin and face.


1. Alice Miller



2. Helena Moeller



3. Layla Peachbloom

[netzerkaiser]

May I come up with one that already happened?

https://pornbox.com/application/watch-page/27598
https://pornbox.com/application/watch-page/27413

The lovely Andy Brown made a come-back about 9 years ago, so full bodied from her previous thin self.

She looked amazing.

[plajvaz]

Regarding ALL pornstars - it would be a really hard choice.

Regarding only LP pornstars, I would choose these:


1. Sindy Rose
Sindy Rose (together with DirtyGardenGirl) is the reason I fell in love with anal prolapse, deep anal insertions, double and triple fisting, peehole insertions...
I think she is still active on her own site, but I hope she will come back on LP as well.




2. Arwen Gold
In my opinion, the greatest LP legend.
She was the reason I came to this site.




3. Sasha Zima
Underrated performer, my personal favorite.
Her haircut, eyes, face - unique, attractive, distinct, sexy!




4. Alysa Gap
She is the reason I fall in love with anal fisting and big gapes (before I discovered anal prolapses).
I am not sure if she is still active outside of LP?




5. Kira Roller
One of the cutest LP girls.
Retired too soon.




6. Veronica Avluv
Very pasionate experienced performer with great anal and piss drinking skills.
I know she said that she will never return to LP. Also, I am not sure if she is still active outside of LP?




7. Simony Diamond
She has the most elegant appearance and very good anal skills.
I am not sure if she fully retired?




8. Nikky Dream
Cute, curly girl, with non-porn look, but very good performer.
Like Simony Diamond, I am not sure if she is fully retired?




9. Monika Wild
Great performer!
I believe she will come back soon.




10. Proxy Paige
One of LP anal legends.
I know she had misunderstandings with LP and I am not sure if she is still performing or only directing now?




For non-LP pornstars, I need to think much more...

[ToryLaneRulez]

Tory Lane

Angel Long


Audrey Hollander

Kelly Wells

any of those in their hetfay workinh for LP

damm that would have been hardvore!!!!!!!

dam so many spelling errors

just to clarify

hetfay should be heyday
workinh should be working
hardvore should be hardcore

[ExtremePornFan]

Luckily, I don't think the grammar police have infiltrated the LP forum..... yet.

I am surprised we don't have a Angel Smalls vote. She would have been second on my list if I was not infatuated with Nikita Bellucci.

[BarryWhite8]

For Euro stars..

Madison Parker - Always enjoyed watching Madison, especialy when she had a bit of acting to do, she always brought a fun vibe to the scene
Annette Schwarz - Would love to see Annette in an LP scene, I know she did extreme stuff for GGG but their aesthetic is trash, the awful lighting & shitty cameras make the most beautiful women look terrible.
Bonny Bon - Amazing performer, the Raul Christian stuff she did was formative to my porn tastes, would love to see her come back

Honourable mention for Sharka Blue, her bonus scene in Fucked On Sight is one of my all time top scenes, she has great energy.

US Stars...

Jynx Maze - Seemed to disappear just as she was getting really fithy, the world of porn seems to just be catching up with her, I'd love to see her again.
Sadie West - Super hot & a little crazy
Renae Cruz - One of my all time favourite latinas.

I'd be happy to see them in their prime or whatever age they are now, I think the oldest is probably Bonny who'd be late 40s now which I reckon I'd be fine with haha.

[sdimpalass]

My number 1, Selen!

R3d52b25ef3a5e7fc8e1122efc02301fc.jpg (31.26 KiB) Viewed 5398 times

ezgif-5-e2ac06aa13.gif (6.68 MiB) Viewed 5398 times

ezgif-5-bb78af8bbd.gif (6.64 MiB) Viewed 5398 times

ezgif-5-37b781b2ea.gif (5.77 MiB) Viewed 5398 times

[paulyshoresituation]

When i mention this, obviously i mean as of right now. But the assumption is they still look close to as good as they did when they were in porn.


So say suzie and lucy lee still look real good as of now, to me that would be the greatest returns of all time. Priscilla as well.


Surely porn fans would go crazy if lucy lee did a return right?

[TheVulture]

Can't believe no-one has mentioned Julie Silver. Top 3 girl of the "golden" Private era and you have to think that somewhere out there she still craves hard anal sex of the kind she could only realistically get in porn. Make it happen!

I haven't given up on Simony Diamond, particularly as I noticed a recent AV/LP scene (from one of the more shoddy studios) that looked like it was probably filmed quite recently. She is a slightly different case in point as she's pretty much unique in traversing that "golden" era and seamlessly fitting into the AV/LP era as well. She only seems to have retired (or semi-retired) maybe 3 or 4 years ago and her earlier AV/LP scenes (mostly for Gonzo) were superb. Her very late AV/LP scenes weren't quite so good for whatever reason so she has unfinished business. Come on Simony! We need you back!

Bit surprised everyone is taking this thread at face value as surely most of you realise that this poster pops up every few months to essentially hide the same agenda behind a shape-shifting sort of question (usually with Lucy Lee as a decoy, as here). Essentially he wants a cast-iron answer from us (!) as to whether Suzie Diamond will ever return and also whether she ever considered doing a bukkake scene back in the day and if so why because she's too good looking for that etc. etc. It's a little pathological I think, albeit I guess harmless. But expect this post to die for a few months at a time and then pop back into life with him going "But seriously? How much would Suzie need? Would she consider it do you think? Why do some people think *x model* is more attractive than Suzie?" etc. etc. If you're genuinely engaged you need to strap yourself in for a long ride.

[zeusanalfreak299]

My number 1, Selen!

She is hot as fuck! What is her full name (porn model name)? Too bad that she wasnt born later for the 2005 - 2015 golden era at legalporno...

[zeusanalfreak299]

Can't believe no-one has mentioned Julie Silver.

I feel so shamed, I forgot JULIE SILVER totally, also JANE DARLING or ELEANOR... jesus... These models were soooo wonderful and stunning compared to 99% of todays models.

[Seraph0257]

Nikita Bellucci, Cecilia Vega, and Lou Charmelle. Cecilia and Lou got out just before the seriously hardcore stuff started, I think they would both be great DAP stars.

[netzerkaiser]

Can't believe no-one has mentioned Julie Silver. Top 3 girl of the "golden" Private era and you have to think that somewhere out there she still craves hard anal sex of the kind she could only realistically get in porn. Make it happen!

I haven't given up on Simony Diamond, particularly as I noticed a recent AV/LP scene (from one of the more shoddy studios) that looked like it was probably filmed quite recently. She is a slightly different case in point as she's pretty much unique in traversing that "golden" era and seamlessly fitting into the AV/LP era as well. She only seems to have retired (or semi-retired) maybe 3 or 4 years ago and her earlier AV/LP scenes (mostly for Gonzo) were superb. Her very late AV/LP scenes weren't quite so good for whatever reason so she has unfinished business. Come on Simony! We need you back!

Bit surprised everyone is taking this thread at face value as surely most of you realise that this poster pops up every few months to essentially hide the same agenda behind a shape-shifting sort of question (usually with Lucy Lee as a decoy, as here). Essentially he wants a cast-iron answer from us (!) as to whether Suzie Diamond will ever return and also whether she ever considered doing a bukkake scene back in the day and if so why because she's too good looking for that etc. etc. It's a little pathological I think, albeit I guess harmless. But expect this post to die for a few months at a time and then pop back into life with him going "But seriously? How much would Suzie need? Would she consider it do you think? Why do some people think *x model* is more attractive than Suzie?" etc. etc. If you're genuinely engaged you need to strap yourself in for a long ride.

I gotta say, I admire the dude.

If you check out the guy he names himself after, he must be aware how ironical his argument is.

Dude is a bit of a genius.

[asaleh001806]

[quote="BarryWhite8"]For Euro stars..

Annette Schwarz - Would love to see Annette in an LP scene, I know she did extreme stuff for GGG but their aesthetic is trash, the awful lighting & shitty cameras make the most beautiful women look terrible.

Love Annette Schwarz and a come back would be nice. Does GGG stand for German Goo Girls?

[TheVulture]

I gotta say, I admire the dude.

If you check out the guy he names himself after, he must be aware how ironical his argument is.

Dude is a bit of a genius.

I seem to recall at the end of the last thread of his you invited him to join you on a tour of Czech Republic looking to track down Lucy Lee. Somehow I'm not sure I see that ending with polite drinks and reminiscences over a barbecue with Lucy's family and friends but probably pauly being thrown in a Prague prison and then deported.

I'm probably a bit harsh in saying he uses Lucy Lee as a decoy. He does like her but his real obsession is with Suzie Diamond, isn't it? Nothing wrong with that to some extent but he just asks the same questions again and again and always with a subtext of "But she's too good looking for porn". I think he needs to get over that and also accept that things change and evolve and move on.

But then it is nice to reminisce about porn of yesteryear. I mentioned in another thread that I dug out a box of VHS porn from the noughties quite recently. While there was little excitement in it as it's like days-old chewing gum even after a long break, it was refreshing to see porn from an era where the guys' vibe was of genuine lust and enjoyment of the girls. Not an aggressive hand in sight anywhere. In terms of old porn vs new porn it's pros and cons, swings and roundabouts etc. The newer harder anal content is amazing but the accompanying "angry dude" vibe is a setback. I miss the eroticism and relaxed nature of old porn, for sure. I'm also quite glad that I got into porn during that older era. If I were 25 now and exposed to current porn as an intro (I'd seen porn before 25 of course but not much by way of hardcore films), I'm not sure it would be so healthy for me somehow. It's hard to tell if my desire to see strong, assertive women exploding with lust was created in that first wave (where that was the general vibe) or simply satisfied. And would I assume that all hardcore (ie not exactly "normal") sex must by definition involve male aggression? Perhaps. I do think that modern porn is in some ways quite unhealthy vis a vis young people's perceptions of sex. It would be interesting indeed to see if the likes of Julie Silver, Claudia Rossi etc. could still "sizzle" in modern porn. Or would they just be prey/bait for inflated male egos and come across as generic inflatable doll types? That's where the interesting conversation is here I think. I'm not sure but I think that they would be somehow "different". What does anyone else think?

[muffmanx]

I gotta say, I admire the dude.

If you check out the guy he names himself after, he must be aware how ironical his argument is.

Dude is a bit of a genius.

I seem to recall at the end of the last thread of his you invited him to join you on a tour of Czech Republic looking to track down Lucy Lee. Somehow I'm not sure I see that ending with polite drinks and reminiscences over a barbecue with Lucy's family and friends but probably pauly being thrown in a Prague prison and then deported.

I'm probably a bit harsh in saying he uses Lucy Lee as a decoy. He does like her but his real obsession is with Suzie Diamond, isn't it? Nothing wrong with that to some extent but he just asks the same questions again and again and always with a subtext of "But she's too good looking for porn". I think he needs to get over that and also accept that things change and evolve and move on.

But then it is nice to reminisce about porn of yesteryear. I mentioned in another thread that I dug out a box of VHS porn from the noughties quite recently. While there was little excitement in it as it's like days-old chewing gum even after a long break, it was refreshing to see porn from an era where the guys' vibe was of genuine lust and enjoyment of the girls. Not an aggressive hand in sight anywhere. In terms of old porn vs new porn it's pros and cons, swings and roundabouts etc. The newer harder anal content is amazing but the accompanying "angry dude" vibe is a setback. I miss the eroticism and relaxed nature of old porn, for sure. I'm also quite glad that I got into porn during that older era. If I were 25 now and exposed to current porn as an intro (I'd seen porn before 25 of course but not much by way of hardcore films), I'm not sure it would be so healthy for me somehow. It's hard to tell if my desire to see strong, assertive women exploding with lust was created in that first wave (where that was the general vibe) or simply satisfied. And would I assume that all hardcore (ie not exactly "normal") sex must by definition involve male aggression? Perhaps. I do think that modern porn is in some ways quite unhealthy vis a vis young people's perceptions of sex. It would be interesting indeed to see if the likes of Julie Silver, Claudia Rossi etc. could still "sizzle" in modern porn. Or would they just be prey/bait for inflated male egos and come across as generic inflatable doll types? That's where the interesting conversation is here I think. I'm not sure but I think that they would be somehow "different". What does anyone else think?

Very much agree with that is said here. Pre-gonzo style porn was much more about lust and the enjoyment of sex and celebration of feminine beauty. Whereas modern mainstream porn tends to lean heavily on male sexual domination over female. I like both for different reasons and moods, but if I have to pick one it would be the earlier ones. Luckily there are still studios making that style of porn and seems to be getting more popular recently again.

[netzerkaiser]

I gotta say, I admire the dude.

If you check out the guy he names himself after, he must be aware how ironical his argument is.

Dude is a bit of a genius.

I seem to recall at the end of the last thread of his you invited him to join you on a tour of Czech Republic looking to track down Lucy Lee. Somehow I'm not sure I see that ending with polite drinks and reminiscences over a barbecue with Lucy's family and friends but probably pauly being thrown in a Prague prison and then deported.

I'm probably a bit harsh in saying he uses Lucy Lee as a decoy. He does like her but his real obsession is with Suzie Diamond, isn't it? Nothing wrong with that to some extent but he just asks the same questions again and again and always with a subtext of "But she's too good looking for porn". I think he needs to get over that and also accept that things change and evolve and move on.

But then it is nice to reminisce about porn of yesteryear. I mentioned in another thread that I dug out a box of VHS porn from the noughties quite recently. While there was little excitement in it as it's like days-old chewing gum even after a long break, it was refreshing to see porn from an era where the guys' vibe was of genuine lust and enjoyment of the girls. Not an aggressive hand in sight anywhere. In terms of old porn vs new porn it's pros and cons, swings and roundabouts etc. The newer harder anal content is amazing but the accompanying "angry dude" vibe is a setback. I miss the eroticism and relaxed nature of old porn, for sure. I'm also quite glad that I got into porn during that older era. If I were 25 now and exposed to current porn as an intro (I'd seen porn before 25 of course but not much by way of hardcore films), I'm not sure it would be so healthy for me somehow. It's hard to tell if my desire to see strong, assertive women exploding with lust was created in that first wave (where that was the general vibe) or simply satisfied. And would I assume that all hardcore (ie not exactly "normal") sex must by definition involve male aggression? Perhaps. I do think that modern porn is in some ways quite unhealthy vis a vis young people's perceptions of sex. It would be interesting indeed to see if the likes of Julie Silver, Claudia Rossi etc. could still "sizzle" in modern porn. Or would they just be prey/bait for inflated male egos and come across as generic inflatable doll types? That's where the interesting conversation is here I think. I'm not sure but I think that they would be somehow "different". What does anyone else think?

Very much agree with that is said here. Pre-gonzo style porn was much more about lust and the enjoyment of sex and celebration of feminine beauty. Whereas modern mainstream porn tends to lean heavily on male sexual domination over female. I like both for different reasons and moods, but if I have to pick one it would be the earlier ones. Luckily there are still studios making that style of porn and seems to be getting more popular recently again.

Two fantastic posts full of wisdom. I really enjoyed reading them!

Vulture, I'd forgotten this until you just reminded me... you really brought a smile to my face after 15 hours on the road... Thanks man!

I seem to recall at the end of the last thread of his you invited him to join you on a tour of Czech Republic looking to track down Lucy Lee. Somehow I'm not sure I see that ending with polite drinks and reminiscences over a barbecue with Lucy's family and friends but probably pauly being thrown in a Prague prison and then deported.

[YuriyProneBone]

If by return you mean BBC Gonzo and BBC GIO then for me it would be:

1. Anita Bellini

2. Lady Dee

Screenshot 2023-03-01 163922.jpg (65.69 KiB) Viewed 4973 times

Screenshot 2023-03-01 164003.jpg (43.49 KiB) Viewed 4973 times

3. Sharon White

Screenshot 2023-03-01 163521.jpg (42.32 KiB) Viewed 4973 times

Screenshot 2023-03-01 163548.jpg (49.06 KiB) Viewed 4973 times

Screenshot 2023-03-01 163610.jpg (25.25 KiB) Viewed 4973 times

Those would be my top 3 2023 BBC gangbang comeback wishlist for 2023 on Gonzo and GIO.

[BarryWhite8]

For Euro stars..

Annette Schwarz - Would love to see Annette in an LP scene, I know she did extreme stuff for GGG but their aesthetic is trash, the awful lighting & shitty cameras make the most beautiful women look terrible.

Love Annette Schwarz and a come back would be nice. Does GGG stand for German Goo Girls?

Yeah the John Thompson stuff, terrible make up, lighting & 1990s digital video camera technology.

[pjfry75]

Gina Wild

[jaxsonm75]

Most of the girls being named are nobodies, respectfully...

You want top 3 returns of A-list elite stars? Here's 3 that come to my mind:

Sasha Grey
Sophie Dee
Jynx Maze

[Viktor Kjartansson]

Alex Black

[paulyshoresituation]

What you mean suzie was mid ass fuck? By that you mean she was an average girl in porn with average ass?


So Lucy Lee would be considered top twenty euro girl of that era or not? i understand lucy was more popular than suzie and had more fans... but what is it about suzie you or others don't find as good looking or amazing compared to lucy?

[antiochethereal]

Based on their popularity i would say these 3:

- Jenna Jameson
- Silvia Saint
- Sasha Grey

Agree but with Jenna doing anal and Katja Kassin instead of Sasha Grey.

[annmsklr5]

definitely

Linda Sweet

[Fstop2000]

Kira Thorn
Sofi Goldfinger
Selvaggia
Evelina Darling
Lita Phoenix
Shrima Malati
Mila Milan
Crystal Greenvelle
Anya Akulova
Clementine Marceau
Lara Onyx

[paulyshoresituation]

How is julie silver on the list? i don't find her attractive at all.


Also, do most agree lucy lee was probably one of the best looking pornstar of all time?


But would any of these girls returning be huge? if suzie or lucy did a return, that would be amazing. Also you think any of the male talent would be excited to do scene with them? like imagine legalporno.

[xxxVIPERxxx]

I think in 5-10 years' time...based on current trajectory...stars like Alexxa Vice and Jolee Love should be in the fray for being some of the top and greatest pornstars of this generation.